Thinking of them, my cheerful mood from moments ago suddenly turned melancholy. And I’d cheer myself up again through Rick, who visited my dreams.
Like always, I reported the day’s events to Rick when he came to see me.
How I’d grown closer to Mary lately, how we toured various parts of the detached palace together, how we now even ate meals together, and so on.
“I’m glad things have improved so much.”
Rick held me in his arms and carefully stroked my hair. He treated me preciously, like handling a valuable jewel.
I smiled softly and raised my hand to stroke his cheek. The vivid sensation of warmth made him seem truly alive.
I rose to meet his eye level and pressed my lips to his. It was our first kiss in a dream.
Rick’s eyes widened unexpectedly.
Why are you surprised? Even in a dream?
I savored his soft lips and slowly tried to enter him.
Ah…
But the moment our tongues touched, I realized. This wasn’t a dream.
Who was the man before me? He was definitely the Rick I knew. He hadn’t changed at all from before.
But he couldn’t exist.
Not Rick, yet exactly like Rick—he wasn’t just imitating like in the past, but had truly become Rick.
Yet he exists… why is that man imitating Rick?
Though momentarily flustered, I showed nothing.
I continued tangling my tongue with his, saliva mixing. Exactly like the kisses Rick had given me. So loving and sweet.
But the kiss that felt sweet just moments ago suddenly felt cold. Like my whole body was covered in goosebumps from tangling with a cold snake’s tongue.
Suddenly it seemed absurd. The kiss I’d found ecstatic when I thought it was Rick—why did it become revolting when I thought of it as that man?
What’s his intention? Is he mocking me?
Maybe he’s pretending to be Rick again to plunge me into despair once more.
I pushed the man away with all my strength and shouted.
“You’re not Rick.”
The red eyes looking at me wavered faintly.
They seemed tangled with all sorts of emotions—sadness, pain, frustration. Like he’d been wounded.
“…I’ve been found out.”
After a brief silence, an answer like a sigh flowed from the man’s mouth.
“Why did you imitate Rick?”
My once-gentle gaze had turned cold.
“Because you wouldn’t acknowledge me.”
The man’s gaze dropped. That face, frowning like he was in agony, seemed so awkward. Maybe because he wore Rick’s expression.
“How could I dare ignore His Majesty the Emperor? You could just act however you want like before. Why did you suddenly change?”
“Because I want to win your heart.”
“My heart? What will you do with it?”
“Because I’ve realized my feelings.”
After giving only stiff answers, he took a deep breath like he’d made a decision and spoke again.
“I realized too late that I love you.”
“Love?”
My eyes widened at the word love. After tormenting me so terribly, now he speaks of love?
I pushed the man away and kept backing up. I didn’t want to be near him right now.
“I know I’ve wronged you terribly. You don’t have to love me like you did before. Just… don’t hate me.”
He clung to me pleadingly.
“Please… You can keep thinking of me as Rick.”
Emotion had entered his once cold, detached voice.
“How can I, when I know you’re not?”
I turned my gaze from him.
Knowing I disliked it, he didn’t touch my body. That small consideration seemed to show he’d changed.
But.
My feelings couldn’t change instantly.
I thought I understood why he was acting like Rick. The physician probably told him. When I said I most wanted to meet Rick, he granted my wish.
In fact, I’d been happy these past few days thinking I could meet Rick even in dreams, so I didn’t feel betrayed by him.
I didn’t know what emotion it was, but the very fact that Rick’s form existed in him made me feel relief deep in my heart.
Perhaps in that brief time, I’d felt something called happiness.
But when I thought about how he wasn’t Rick, but the murderer who killed my father and the Suffolk family, feelings of hatred surged.
So I hated yet didn’t hate him, disliked yet didn’t dislike him—two contradictory emotions tangled, complicating my heart. Like walking through a maze in fog.
Even I couldn’t understand my own heart.
“Elena!”
The tangled thoughts tormented me until I finally lost consciousness.
I thought I heard the man’s scream from far away, but it grew more distant, fading into somewhere far away.
* * *
When I came to, I was lying on the bed. And beside me, the physician looked at me with pitying eyes.
“Are you awake?”
“Ah… yes.”
I looked around. Not seeing the face of the man who’d confused me, I breathed a sigh of relief.
“How was it, meeting Rick, whom you wanted to see so badly?”
“So it was your doing after all.”
I answered with a deep sigh.
“I had him do it hoping you’d see him properly. I hoped you’d recognize that those two people are the same person. So please, don’t deny His Majesty’s existence.”
The physician spoke pleadingly. He must have heard that I pushed him away the moment I realized that man wasn’t Rick.
“I know. I know, but…”
Looking at that man’s face, I couldn’t not know. That he was Rick yet not Rick.
But I didn’t want to accept it. The more I thought of that terrible past, the more I felt that way.
So Rick and that man had to be different people to me. Even knowing he was treating me well, accepting it right now was impossible.
“I’m sorry to say this, but His Majesty is also pitiable.”
Seeing my discomfort, the physician said something meaningful.
“Pitiable?”
“His Majesty wasn’t violent or hot-tempered from childhood. His environment changed him.”
But he didn’t seem inclined to tell me more.
I didn’t ask further either. But that phrase “environment” kept bothering me.
I suddenly became curious.
“Will you tell me about the man called Kalian?”
So I asked Mary, who entered the room in shifts as the physician left.
“Actually, I don’t know much. There are hardly any good stories—is that okay?”
She smiled awkwardly.
“I don’t care. He hasn’t been a good man to me so far anyway.”
“As you can see, he’s cruel without mercy or compassion. He treats human lives lightly too. I wanted to say only good things, but there really aren’t any…”
Mary glanced at me with an embarrassed expression.
“Then I’ll ask questions and you answer. What does he like most?”
I asked with a faint smile.
“He likes going to battlefields. He especially likes seeing enemy soldiers fallen before him, covered in blood. Oh, he also likes giving people despair in their happiest moments. And what else was there…”
Mary scratched her head. Kalian apparently didn’t have many likes.
“Actually, the only thing to praise is his handsome appearance. Isn’t that funny? I want you two to work out, yet I’ve only listed his faults.”
“I already knew all that.”
“But he has changed because of you lately. I’ve been seeing sides of him I never saw before. You know how shocked I was? I never imagined he’d be gentle with anyone.”
“…”
I’d been smiling hearing words close to slander, but the moment I heard Kalian had changed, my smile vanished.
I knew he’d changed too.
Well. Rather than changed, maybe that’s his hidden side. Because it’s closer to Rick’s personality than the personality Mary described.
“I hope you’ll understand His Majesty better.”
When I gave no answer, Mary held my hand with a lonely smile.
“What do you mean?”
“What you see on the surface isn’t everything. There’s a reason he became a cold-blooded killer.”
She said the same thing as the physician. That there were reasons for that man’s cruelty.
“What reason?”
Mary smiled at me and told me about Kalian’s past.
Starting with the story of brothers who received no love, the Empress who tried to kill him, the guard knight who betrayed Kalion, and… the terrible incident my father committed.
“To protect the fragile Kalion and preserve his own life, he had no choice but to kill the assassins. In doing so, he gradually became cold and cruel.”
“I see… I didn’t know.”
I didn’t know the detailed circumstances of what my father had done. These were stories I was hearing for the first time.
At that moment, my frozen heart seemed to thaw with a scraping sound. A subtle emotion seeped in—cold and painful yet also hot.
That man had experienced such terrible things. More than my hardships, he’d lived through and endured much harder times.
His bleak past, the sense of duty to protect his fragile brother—these might have made him into an even more cruel and ruthless man.
While thinking that man was so pitiful, I simultaneously felt ashamed, thinking I was relatively a whiner and a spoiled child.
My life, which I’d thought boring and dull, was like heaven compared to his.
I received my father’s love, and though not wealthy, had no trouble eating and living, and while not many people liked me, hardly anyone disliked me.
Yet I’d only complained that life was boring and lonely. Compared to him, I was just a spoiled, immature child…
Tears flowed endlessly from my eyes.
Separate from the cruel things he’d done to me, his life was so pitiful. And I felt so sorry.
Because the one who made his life most unhappy and miserable was my father.
“It would have been better to just let me leave. Even I would find my face terrible to look at. Why did he save me when I only cause pain?”
“Pain? His Majesty keeps you by his side because he’s already forgiven you. Rather, he suffered greater pain when he learned you tried to take your life.”
“Can forgiveness come so easily? Wasn’t he tormenting me all this time because he hated me?”
Hearing about forgiveness, I tilted my head. Could that word come so easily after tormenting me so much?
“At first, he thought he only had feelings of hatred. But no. He had mixed love and hate. Tormenting you was also a kind of expression of affection. He’s truly a bad man, isn’t he?”
“…”
“Please understand His Majesty’s true feelings. Since you seek another man in him, he’s suffering too. That’s why jealousy made him torment you even more.”
“…”
“Think carefully. The man called Rick you missed so much is actually the same person as His Majesty. Though they seem completely different, he’s someone who fully remembers Rick’s memories. So he’s a man who can show Rick’s side anytime.”
Mary said the same thing as the physician. To acknowledge that man now.
Thinking about it, I’d denied his existence from the start. Ever since the moment he killed my father before my eyes.
I’d never properly called him by name either. I thought he was just a man wearing Rick’s skin, so to me, Kalian was a man who didn’t exist.
But I’d known all along. That the two were the same person.
I just didn’t want to accept it, so I denied it. Because I knew Rick’s feelings for me were sincere.
Father said he’d been under a spell that made him share my emotions, but when I met him after he’d lost his memory again, I vaguely sensed Father’s words weren’t true.
Even without memories, he didn’t deny that I was his lover, asked if I wouldn’t come with him when I told him to leave, and didn’t refuse when I suggested we kiss.
Though seemingly harsh, the time when he didn’t refuse the hand I extended was probably when he was most honest with me.
That’s why I might have kept denying that man who showed me hatred. Saying you who don’t love me aren’t Rick, my Rick loves me.
But.
After shifting my thinking and acknowledging his existence, I finally understood his heart.
Though he hated me enough to want to kill me, he couldn’t actually kill me because his hatred meant the feelings he held for me were that strong.
I’d been continuously loved by that man. I just didn’t know because it wasn’t the form of love I wanted. Because I never thought torment could be an expression of affection.
“Do you understand now?”
As more tears poured from my eyes, Mary patted my back.
“Yes. I think I understand.”
I’d been too focused on myself.
I never even had the right to forgive him in the first place. Because none of this would have happened if my father hadn’t killed his brother and kidnapped him.