It was laughable that she had believed, even for a brief moment, that he cared for her. And embarrassing. Even the feeling that Valen had known her well now struck her as something to be deeply ashamed of.
He had never been trying to understand her or look out for her. At most, he might have been trying to read her, to figure out how to get her to do what he wanted.
“I’m such a fool.”
She felt like she might cry. She couldn’t stand the thought of herself for nearly having opened her heart to him, even briefly. Valen Castoria was the very model of a typical nobleman who placed family and duty above all else, and for people like that, something as trivial as another person’s feelings didn’t matter.
Covering her mouth with her hand, Yuria walked past Valen and out of the study. Valen could only stand frozen, watching her disappear.
His breath coming in short, constricted bursts, Valen slowly undid the top button of his shirt. The windowpane fogged with his warm breath. Loosening the collar he had kept buttoned all the way to the throat, he could at least breathe again.
Outside by the lake, the young child was still running and playing happily. It was a sight that felt entirely foreign to Valen. In his childhood, childlike innocence and mischief had not been permitted.
Valen reached down and pulled the neatly tucked hem of his shirt out from his trousers. Beneath it was a long, raised scar. Running his fingers over it without thinking, Valen was pulled back into the past by reflex.
His grandfather, the former Duke Castoria, now dead, had been unusually concerned with how others perceived him.
Perhaps it was because there was no other heir to carry on the line, but the grandfather Valen had at first taken for simply strict grew more and more forceful with him as time went on. He had believed without question his grandfather’s reproaches that his parents were far too indulgent with their son. So when his grandfather struck him for the first time one day, he hadn’t been particularly shocked.
Of course, his grandfather’s *buse did not end with a single blow. The Duke Castoria of that era grew sharper and more volatile with each passing year as death drew nearer. What had begun as a few strikes in private, away from other eyes, transformed into something else entirely: being taken to a hidden room and subjected to pain.
He believed Valen was not sufficiently prepared. He would say, as though it were a refrain, that Valen fell far short of their standards, and that it was because of this that Castoria had been made a laughingstock, and that his great-aunt had been killed as a result.
Behind the veneer of maturity lay wounds and pain carved into a tender heart. Valen had worked relentlessly to conceal them.
The Castoria manor was vast, and with that vastness came many places that went unseen. There were quite a few spaces in the basement that others didn’t know about. His grandfather used to lock him in one of them. The damp and dimly lit room had been more than enough to frighten a child.
The texture of the scar beneath his fingertips was vivid. It was the mark left by his grandfather, who had chosen places that would not catch his parents’ eyes and struck him with a leather strap. Valen had sometimes been bound, kicked, and hung from chains. And at times, whenever word came of praise for the young lady of Bellaris, the beatings would grow worse.
They had been bound together in a relationship that could only bring each other pain.
Bringing up the subject of children in front of Yuria had been a mistake. It was because a scene had suddenly appeared before him, vivid and clear. A beautiful boy with hair dark as ebony, taking after her, and a mischievous little girl with eyes just like his own. If the ones playing outside right now had been those children.
‘Agnes. Nico.’
He turned those names over in his mouth, names he would never speak aloud again. The image of them toddling toward him with bright, carefree faces at the sound of their names was still clear before his eyes.
It wasn’t only that. The time Yuria had first become pregnant. The time they had put their heads together trying to decide what name to give the child. The moment their firstborn came into the world and drew its first breath.
All of those moments swept through him and clawed at his chest. Longing for children he could no longer see or touch was an unbearably painful thing. He had known the cost of this choice, and yet he had made it anyway. He could only hope they would forgive him.
Valen had not been a capable father, but he had at least tried to be a good parent. He had revisited his own scarred childhood and made a promise to himself, again and again, never to inflict that same pain. Yuria had been the same.
They had loved each other, and they had loved their children. There had been such a time. A time when they had built a family free from the shackles and constraints of society, on nothing but pure feeling.
And so, while he understood why Yuria had misunderstood him, it also ached. Valen had wanted their child in the purest sense. Not because of the family’s wishes or a nobleman’s duty, but a child born because Yuria herself wanted one.
Yet Valen remained doubtful. Whether someone who had lived through such an unhappy past could truly raise children well. He had never gotten to see what kind of adults those children would grow into. He didn’t know what other mistakes he might have made if time had simply continued on.
So perhaps things were better left as they were now. Creating something precious he could not take responsibility for would only compound the pain.
His breathing had calmed without his noticing. Valen stepped slowly away from the window. Looking around the study, he felt that familiar, warm feeling wrap around him. He had always run to this place. The study was his refuge, his only sanctuary.
He knew that Yuria, having left her home behind, felt something similar here. That was precisely why he had hoped she would come to think of the study as a place of comfort. And yet, without meaning to, he had pushed her away again.
“Stupid Valen Castoria.”
Muttering that self-reproach, he pressed his fingers lightly to his forehead. What was done could not be undone, and he knew well that even if it could be, there were things that couldn’t be changed. And at least in this moment, he believed he was on the right path, moving in the direction he had intended.
No matter how much Yuria misunderstood him and hated him, this was unavoidable. For her sake, for the future version of her, he could bear her hatred any number of times. What mattered was a future in which Yuria was alive, not her love for him right now.
‘You must not place unconditional trust in those who show you kindness.’
Lady Chiara’s words were something Yuria was still turning over and over in her mind. Wondering whether they applied to Valen as well.
But she was not a fool. Those words were clearly aimed at Halo Estian.
Chiara Ovard, telling her not to trust the woman she had thought was nearly her only supporter in all of Montagna. Objectively speaking, it was only natural to trust Halo over Chiara, who had shown her open hostility.
Yet in her current situation, Yuria could not arrive at any clear judgment about who to trust and who to be wary of. The one thing she knew for certain was that being wary of everyone was more to her benefit than trusting anyone at all.
“My lady, is something troubling you?”
The attending physician taking her pulse asked. He was a doctor Valen had insisted on assigning to her, no matter how many times she had said she was fine.
“No, nothing is wrong. How long will I need to be seen?”
“I have been ordered to check on you every day until the young lord gives his leave.”
One fall into the water had already caused this much fuss. If she came down with an illness on top of it, she imagined he would turn the whole household upside down.
“Your husband must care for you a great deal, my lady.”
Yuria barely stopped herself from scoffing. No, he simply doesn’t want me dying and stirring up conflict between the families, leaving him with an unfavorable verdict.
She had found his fussing utterly insufferable at first, but lately she had come to feel almost grateful for it. After all, she could only achieve her goal if she stayed alive.
Wearing a practiced smile, Yuria replied pleasantly.
“Of course. He thinks of my wellbeing so much that it’s almost overwhelming at times.”
Anyone listening might think she was complaining about being too blessed with an attentive husband. That was precisely what Yuria intended.
A happy couple. Two people who looked more harmonious than anyone. That was the mask they had to wear.
“I’m glad to hear it.”
Having come only because he had been ordered to by the young lord of Castoria, the attending physician had not quite managed to fully conceal his hostility toward the woman from Bellaris. He began packing up his things with a somewhat cold manner. The reconciliation between the ducal houses meant little to people like him. The personal feeling of contempt for those from Il Mare simply came first.
The moment the physician left the room, someone else entered. Catching sight of her husband’s face, Yuria didn’t know how to react and simply held his gaze in silence.
“How are you feeling?”
“As I always say, nothing is wrong.”
“Would you be able to meet with the crown prince?”