Even through words full of worry, no color returned to Isabella’s pale face. He reached out, unable to help himself, and moved to gently touch her cheek. It was the same instinct from before, driven by concern without thinking. But his hand never made contact.
“……”
“Isa……bella?”
“I’m going to rest.”
Isabella knocked his approaching hand away without mercy, shot to her feet, left those firm words behind, and walked out of the dining room. What did I do wrong? Declen rose quickly, flustered, and moved to follow her. He was not offended. He was worried about her chalk-white face, and the fact that she had barely touched her food was driving him to the edge of panic.
What on earth had happened to make her turn so much colder overnight? He followed after her in a hurry, came to a stop in front of Isabella’s bedroom, and stood there for a moment, steadying his breath.
He knew he had to let her go. She might not remember, but she had suffered for far too long. That was why he knew he had to release her. He knew he should not let himself get close, and that even if he did, he had to pull back.
“……”
He wanted to hold on. He wanted to hold on by any means. He wanted to keep her at his side. He wanted to hold her when she cried and make her laugh even more when she smiled. But did he have the right?
Declen Clerc. Do you think you have the right? He asked himself, but there was only one answer.
Declen Clerc had no such right. He had committed a sin against Isabella Piper that could never be washed clean. He knew all too well that dying in her place hundreds, thousands of times over would not be enough to atone for it. That was why Declen Clerc could not bring himself to reach for what he wanted.
“Your Grace?”
While Declen stood there hesitating, the physician the servants had summoned arrived and looked at him with a puzzled expression, standing blankly in front of the door.
“……Examine the grand duchess.”
“Pardon?”
“Examine her thoroughly. I don’t want her to be in pain anywhere.”
“Yes, Your Grace.”
Pressing down the urge to watch her be examined, Declen turned away. Even this moment was a luxury for someone without the right.
* * *
― Baron Piper killed your parents.
Looking back now, those words had been an obvious lie. But the Declen of that time had not had the judgment to see through them. That was his excuse, for whatever it was worth now.
― Don’t lie to me.
― Have I ever lied to you?
She hadn’t. If anything, more of what the woman had said had turned out to be true. She had been truly remarkable. She seemed to know everything happening in the world, predicting events before they occurred and identifying the culprits behind cases they had been unable to solve. Her divine power never seemed to run dry, flowing endlessly. That was why she had been so beloved by the people of the empire.
Saint Aria Laird. The woman who had become greater in the empire than the emperor himself under that name came to Declen one day and opened her mouth.
And she had dug into the wounds of his childhood, wounds he had never spoken of to anyone, not even to Isabella.
― This is also the truth.
― ……
― Just like everything else I have shown you.
It’s a lie. It has to be a lie. What reason would Baron Piper have to kill his parents? The gap in their ranks was so vast that they had never even crossed paths. If not for the prophecy, if not for Avilion, Declen would never have known Isabella Piper existed. He remembered how grateful he had been to Avilion for that. If that small woman had already been in someone else’s arms. The mere thought of it made the blood in his veins run cold. It was something he could not even bring himself to imagine. And yet he was supposed to believe that the father of the Isabella he loved so dearly had killed his parents.
― That cannot be.
― What if it is?
― ……
― Are you refusing to believe me because he is your lover’s father?
― ……
― Brenov.
When Declen refused to believe her, another name slipped out. The name of the house that stood most opposed to the Clerc family.
― You must be aware that Brenov and the Piper family have dealings with each other.
― Even families on the worst of terms maintain basic contact.
The Clercs were no different. Relations could be terrible and they were still nobles. They had to see each other at every imperial council meeting, so cutting ties entirely was not an option. And the Clerc family had its own business ventures, which made it even more so.
― Are you aware that the Brenov marquisate has been secretly supporting the Piper barony for some time?
― Do I need to personally track every minor noble house that receives patronage?
― You know that’s not what I’m talking about.
He did know. What they had demanded in return for that patronage was something only they knew. And yet why did he feel he already understood? He hadn’t been told, and yet he understood all too well, and he hated himself for it. He wanted to shatter his own head on the spot so he could no longer comprehend those words.
― Why would Baron Piper kill the late Grand Duke and Grand Duchess Clerc, my parents? He had no reason to.
― Baron Piper was originally a fallen noble. You must know this.
He did. Through the mismanagement of previous generations, the Piper family had come to the brink of ruin. But they survived. Whether through Brenov’s patronage or the baron’s own ability, the small venture he had barely managed to start began to sail smoothly, and the baron’s family rose, slowly and steadily. And at the height of his business success, he had met and married the daughter of another baron’s house, and Isabella was born.
Though her mother had died from a difficult labor, Isabella came into the world that way, and the baron had raised his newborn daughter with fierce devotion, with no time to grieve. That was as much as Declen knew. His parents’ death had happened before Isabella was born, and only a few years after Declen himself had been born.
For reasons unknown, the grand ducal couple had needed to travel to their territory. On the way down a road running alongside a cliff, a wheel on the carriage broke and the speed could not be slowed. There was no cargo, but the weight of the carriage itself was enough to send it sliding without stopping, and the carriage carrying the grand duke and duchess was thrown over the cliff. The guards. The coachmen. There had been no time for anyone to do anything. And so Declen was left alone. But fortunately, there was someone he could trust. Until young Declen came of age, the family was looked after by his father’s most cherished uncle.
It was fortunate the man had no ambitions for power, but he had no ability to manage the family either. After Declen had grown enough and inherited the title, his uncle hastily handed the family over and left. When Declen checked the family’s finances for the first time after taking over, he had seriously wondered whether he might have to sell the title, but he did not give up. He scraped together every coin he had and went into business, went to war to earn money, and earned Avilion’s recognition to claim the position of captain of the Holy Knights. And just as his life was beginning to flourish, he met Isabella. A love that would never come again.
The one love, the one heart, he could not afford to lose and must not lose. And now he was told that the father of that love had killed his parents.
“……”
He did not believe it. He was not foolish enough to accept those words on the spot. He needed to investigate. But where to start, and how? It was such a long time ago. Would any records even remain? Isabella’s father was already dead. How was he supposed to find anything? But he could not simply believe it, nor could he simply dismiss it.
― Your expression is complicated.
― ……
― You don’t have to believe me, and you can believe me if you like. I am simply telling you the truth.
Whether he said anything or not, the woman seemed to grow tired of him sitting there in silence, set down her barely touched teacup, and rose from her seat.
― That is all I had to say. I’ll be on my way.
― ……If this is truly the truth, why are you telling me?
If it was true, if it was real, why had she told him? If he hadn’t known, if only he hadn’t known, things would have been better.
― Because I felt sorry for you, marrying her without knowing anything.
― ……
― Of course, she herself wouldn’t have known the full details either.
― ……
― Can you truly accept as your grand duchess a woman who was raised on the money paid for your parents’ deaths?
That was not the point. If Baron Piper had truly been the one responsible for his parents’ deaths, what was he supposed to do? Was he supposed to let Isabella go? How could he marry a woman from the family that had killed his parents, whose faces he could no longer even remember?
― Then I will take my leave.
― ……
― You don’t have to believe me. If you choose not to and marry the young Lady Piper anyway, I will keep my mouth shut. And if you learn the full truth and leave her because of it, I will keep my mouth shut then too.
The woman with the face of an angel whispered words like a devil’s murmur and left the estate. Even after she was gone, Declen could not move from where he sat. Time seemed to have stopped in that spot.
“……”
Should he look into it? Or should he bury it as it was? It was already over and done with, and looking into it would not bring anyone back. Did he really need to overturn something that had already been laid to rest just to know the truth?
It was agonizing. What was the right thing to do?
― Declen Clerc. Just remember that your parents always loved you.
His uncle’s voice rang in his ears, the uncle who was probably enjoying a leisurely life somewhere far away by now. Just remember that your parents always loved you. Those were the words his uncle had said before handing over the grand duke’s title and leaving.