“That was the longest I’ve ever managed to endure.”
Cadel added that he had spent countless nights testing his limits and trying to see how long he could endure it for, but that anything beyond that remained impossible.
Jaina’s eyes widened slightly.
She had never imagined that he had gone to such lengths.
Violet, the one he needed, would always be at his side. She had assumed there was no reason for him to put himself through such agony just to see how long he could last.
As this sank in, Cadel spoke again.
“In the end, though, it doesn’t change the fact that I need Violet.”
“……”
“And that if she were to disappear, there would come a night when I would suffer… and die.”
Jaina stared at him.
“I truly wouldn’t care. Even if you vanished and my husband suffered himself to death.”
The words she had said to Violet kept echoing in her mind. Although she had pretended to remain calm, she realized then that her remark had hurt him.
“I—”
“I have no desire to show how narrow-minded I can be, Jaina.”
Cadel cut her off and took a step back. Then, with a faint smile that was almost too subtle to see, he said,
“I’m doing my best in my own way.”
For some reason, that smile pierced straight through her heart.
A sudden wave of sadness hit her so hard that she felt she might collapse to her knees and cry. To stop herself from crying, Jaina bit down hard on the tender flesh inside her cheek and averted her gaze.
Even if Cadel was doing his best, it wouldn’t change the truth: Rainy nights would continue to be spent with Violet until the day he died.
There were still unanswered questions about the curse. She intended to investigate whether it could be broken. But what would truly change, even if it could be?
Even if Cadel were freed from the curse, he wouldn’t abandon Violet overnight. Once released from it, Violet would probably stay in the Grand Duchy.
No matter what happened, the tangled bond that had once driven Jaina to take her own life would not simply unravel.
In this new life she had been given, she did not want to suffer again, consumed by jealousy over a connection she did not fully understand.
“Is it truly necessary for you to go that far?”
Jaina turned her head and met Cadel’s gaze directly.
“The person you need doesn’t seem like someone who would ever betray you.”
Cadel’s expression hardened instantly.
“……”
“So when you want to, you can simply be with her, can’t you?”
“Jaina.”
“I’m tired. I’ll be going now.”
It seemed as if Cadel were about to say something more, but Jaina deliberately refused to listen. She fled the study. nIf she heard even one hopeful word, she was afraid that her resolve would crumble.
‘Why is it still like this…?’
When she first experienced regression, she was certain that she would be able to cast aside this exhausting emotion.
She believed she could discard it. She had even convinced herself that she already had.
However, as time passed and she found herself standing before Cadel time and again, she fell for him once more, helplessly and without resistance.
Jealousy rose within her unbidden over the nights he spent with Violet. She stubbornly denied it, but her mind and heart were not in agreement.
Though it felt pathetic, that was simply how the heart worked. As long as she did not reveal her feelings, she told herself, everything would be fine.
If she could stop herself from becoming too involved, then when it was all over, she could quietly return to the Spirit Village and live there in peace.
Or so she believed.
***
Left alone, Cadel stared blankly at the floor beneath his feet.
“Curse me with whatever you wish—just bring Jaina back to life!”
“I don’t care if you forget me! I don’t care if you never love me again! As long as you’re alive… that’s enough!”
The memory of the day she died came flooding back. He remembered standing before the Elim Tree and striking it repeatedly with the black axe that had been passed down through his family for generations. He had screamed in despair for her to come back.
When the woman he loved died, nothing else mattered.
At the time, he truly believed that her mere existence was enough. That as long as she was breathing, as long as she was standing there and meeting his gaze, he would be satisfied.
Sometimes he wondered if the reason they had both returned to the past with all their memories intact was because of the curse on the axe.
Ironically, because of that curse, a fragile hope had taken root within him — perhaps this time he might be able to draw closer to Jaina than before.
So he sought Adil’s counsel. He tried to change himself. But while he struggled to bridge the gap between them, Jaina remained cold.
Having also returned with her memories intact, she declared that she never wanted to live as she once had, not even for a second time.
She said it plainly.
When everything was over, she would seek a divorce.
It felt as though the sky itself had collapsed on top of him. Yet he had no right to stop her.
Not when he had been forced to leave her side and return to Violet, even in moments of danger. A man like that could not claim to hold her back.
Knock. Knock.
Lost in thought and staring blankly at the floor, Cadel lifted his head at the sound of knocking.
Before he could respond, the door creaked open and Violet’s face appeared through the narrow gap.
“May I come in?”
He had told her dozens of times not to linger anywhere near the study, yet she still entered it as if it were her own room.
“No.”
“Why not?”
“What do you mean, why? This is—”
“You called for the Grand Duchess without hesitation.”
Violet cut him off, pouting. Her eyes, fixed on him, brimmed with hurt.
Cadel let out a long sigh.
“Listen. You seem to be mistaken about something. Jaina is different from you. She is—”
“I know. She’s the Grand Duchess.”
Violet stepped fully inside and closed the door behind her.
“But that’s just a title, isn’t it?”
“…What?”
“She doesn’t handle any of the Grand Duchess’s duties. She just occupies the position because she’s a former saintess—like a figurehead, nothing more—”
“Violet!”
Cadel’s voice echoed sharply and coldly through the room.
Startled by the sudden shout, Violet flinched. As she watched him cautiously, he strode towards her in long, decisive strides.
He reached past her shoulder and flung the closed study door wide open.
In that instant, his eyes met Jaina’s.
“Oh—it’s nothing urgent. I simply forgot to mention one thing.”
Jaina’s gaze shifted to Violet, who was standing directly in front of Cadel.
To anyone looking on, it seemed as though he was about to pull her into a hug. Her throat tightened painfully.
Nevertheless, she forced herself to carry on, pretending that nothing was wrong.
“I plan to visit the Spirit Village early tomorrow morning. Although Lord Elysion asked me to wait, I think I’ll feel better if I see for myself how things are.”
“……”
“I’m sorry for interrupting, then.”
Truth be told, she had come back to apologize. She was troubled by the thought that Cadel might have overheard her conversation with Violet.
Had she known he was with Violet, she would never have come back.
Caught off guard by the unexpected sight, she blurted out the first thing that came to mind. ‘Visiting the spirit village wouldn’t be a bad idea anyway,’ she told herself, hurriedly turning away.
But in the next instant, Cadel seized her wrist.
“Don’t go.”
At his words, both Jaina and Violet froze.
“I’ve said what I needed to say.”
Jaina looked down at the hand gripping her wrist.
“Jaina, I—”
“Cadel, you should finish what you were discussing with me first.”
Violet grasped Cadel’s wrist with both hands—the same wrist that held Jaina.
‘This is exactly why I decided I wouldn’t get entangled with them any longer.’
The situation was repeating itself, just like the past. Jaina squeezed her eyes shut.
‘Pull yourself together. You swore you wouldn’t be shaken by this kind of emotion ever again.’
Steeling herself, she opened her eyes and twisted her wrist firmly out of Cadel’s grasp.
“I’ve finished speaking. Please continue your conversation.”
Then she fled.
From behind, she heard Cadel call her name. A moment later, Violet’s softer voice followed. But Jaina did not slow her steps even for a second.
‘See? I told you to get a grip.’
She walked toward her chambers at nearly a run, biting down hard on the tender flesh inside her cheek.
***
“Jaina!”
“The Grand Duchess said she was finished speaking.”
Cadel tried to follow Jaina, who had not so much as turned her head at his call, but Violet caught hold of him.
“Do not lay your hands on me carelessly, Violet.”
His voice was frighteningly cold as he rebuked her. Violet released him at once.
“But you were speaking with me first.”
Her voice trembled with grievance as she blocked his path, standing directly in front of him. Because of her, he could not go after Jaina.
‘What in the world is this…?’
A suffocating frustration pressed against his chest. Cadel clenched his jaw.
“I’m sorry for comparing the Grand Duchess to a puppet. That was a slip of the tongue. But allowing her into the study just because she holds the title of Grand Duchess—”
Gradually, Violet’s constant complaining faded into the background.
It was a presence that he could not ignore.
He could neither treat it carelessly nor decisively abandon it.
Ultimately, he began to wonder if his true curse was Violet herself, a presence that would be inseparable from his life forever.