He had said he would hear what kind of b*llshit they had to offer, yet the moment they sat down, Choi Dae-sik launched into a one-sided outpouring of grievances.
“I’ve been driving since I was twenty. Do you honestly think I couldn’t tell the accelerator from the brake while driving with my pregnant wife in the car? I’m telling you, it was sudden unintended acceleration!”
Yeon-seo quietly looked at the photographs laid out on the table. Wedding pictures of Choi Dae-sik and his late wife, photos from their newlywed days, an ultrasound image of their baby.
And even his wife’s funeral portrait.
“Losing my wife and child is already more than I can bear, and now you’re calling it driver error? You’ll have me coughing up blood until I die! If you won’t answer for what happened to me, who will?”
Bang!
Choi Dae-sik slammed his hand down on the table.
It had started out as an ordinary day. His wife was sitting beside him in the passenger seat while he drove. With her seatbelt loosened around her rounded belly, she chatted happily along to her favorite songs.
Throughout the drive, she talked about their future together. When their baby was born. When their child would finally come into the world — it was just around the corner.
What would they name the baby? Who would the baby look more like? What kind of child would they grow up to be?
And what kind of parents would they become?
“What on earth did I do wrong? You said it was a good car, so I bought it! What other crime have I committed? Is surviving alone a crime now? I should have died too! But I didn’t! Is that my f*cking crime?”
They had probably never imagined that their life together could end.
What became of the husband afterwards? The wife who had been breathing beside him was gone. The family he had dreamed of building with her was gone. Was saying that his world had collapsed enough to describe that loss? Could saying that he was merely existing because he could not die come close to capturing it?
He must have resented being the only one left, forced to drag himself through each day. After losing his beloved wife so unjustly, perhaps railing at the world was only human. It was perhaps the most natural thing he could do.
“You manufacture and sell a car like that, and then you blame an innocent man? Explain that to me. What are you going to do about it? How are you going to take responsibility?”
Choi Dae-sik’s voice thundered through the café. His attorneys tried to calm him down, but it was only after he had drunk a glass of water that his breathing finally steadied.
The anguish in his voice weighed heavily on Yeon-seo’s heart. After a moment, she spoke. As heartbreaking as his story was, she could not lose sight of the facts or her duty as a lawyer.
“First, I’m deeply sorry for your tragic loss. May your wife rest in peace.”
“What? Rest in peace? Who are you to say that about my wife? Did you come here just to twist the knife with that b*llshit?”
Just as he seemed to be settling down, Choi Dae-sik raised his voice again. He refilled his empty glass, and Yeon-seo noticed his wedding ring.
As he drank, she kept her eyes on the ring. After studying it for a moment, she continued in a composed, businesslike tone.
“The National Forensic Service’s final report concluded that the vehicle inspection revealed no evidence of a defect. That report will be submitted as evidence.”
She took the documents from her bag and handed them to Choi Dae-sik’s attorneys.
“Scenarios involving failures in the transmission system were recreated under various conditions, but those tests likewise revealed no particular problems.”
As the attorneys leafed through the documents, Choi Dae-sik glared at her.
“That’s just what you people are saying! I’m the one who drove the car, and I’m telling you I’ve been wronged! It happened to me, so why do you get to say it didn’t?”
“If the vehicle had accelerated unintentionally, you would have pressed the brake as hard as you could to stop it, Mr. Choi. That kind of force leaves an imprint of the shoe’s tread on the brake pedal.”
Yeon-seo handed over several photographs and more documents.
Choi Dae-sik fell silent. He suddenly recalled the shoes the investigators had collected after the accident. They had asked for them, and he had handed them over without a second thought.
“The forensic examination found no tread imprints on the brake pedal. That means you did not press the brake with significant force.”
“…What? So what? That can happen! It’s not like it leaves a mark every single time!”
“Yes, that’s correct. It doesn’t happen every time. If the tread pattern isn’t distinct, an imprint may not be detectable.”
“Exactly! That’s what I’m saying!”
“But a pedal imprint was found on the sole of your shoe, Mr. Choi. That’s unusual, isn’t it?”
Yeon-seo looked at the attorneys.
“The examination confirmed that the imprint on your shoe matched the accelerator pedal. Likewise, an imprint matching your shoe’s tread was found on the accelerator.”
“…”
“That is evidence that you pressed the accelerator with significant force.”
When Yeon-seo finished speaking, Choi Dae-sik’s attorneys began whispering to each other. It was a sign that things were taking an unfavorable turn.
Choi Dae-sik hurriedly stopped the video recording. Then he shot to his feet.
“Who the hell are you? Who do you think you are, coming all the way here to spout this sh*t about pedals and imprints? Now you’re even finding fault with the soles of my shoes?”
“Mr. Choi, please sit down. You can’t behave like this. Let’s talk—”
His attorneys tried to restrain him, but Choi Dae-sik was already beside himself.
“You think I took time out during business hours to listen to this b*llshit? What? So I couldn’t tell the brake from the accelerator and stomped on the wrong pedal? I’ve never had an accident! Not once since I got my license!”
“Anyone can make a mistake. Your past driving record does not account for what happened in this instance.”
“Hey! Do you take me for a f*cking idiot? Forget all of it. Bring my wife back. Bring my baby back, you bastards!”
“We cannot agree to any of your demands, including the payment of two billion won. Please consider Baekmun Motors’ official position carefully. If you withdraw the lawsuit and stop posting malicious videos based on your own interpretation of events, we may be willing to offer assistance out of a sense of moral responsibility.”
“Moral responsibility? Withdraw the lawsuit? You crazy b*tch!”
Choi Dae-sik thr*st both hands towards Yeon-seo. Thinking he was about to grab her by the collar, she quietly closed her eyes.
But his hands never reached her.
Yeon-seo opened her eyes, her lips parting slightly.
Hee-dae had stood up and positioned himself within Choi Dae-sik’s reach, offering his own collar instead. Realizing he had grabbed Hee-dae by mistake, Choi Dae-sik craned his neck to look up at the much taller man.
“Who the hell are you? Why are you suddenly butting in?”
“As you can see, she handles the brains. I handle the physical side.”
“…”
“I can take a hit better than she can.”
Hee-dae tilted his head as though inviting him to shake him as much as he liked.
After faltering for a moment, Choi Dae-sik’s eyes blazed again.
“You f*cking corporate bastards—!”
As Choi Dae-sik tightened his grip on Hee-dae’s collar, the attorneys all sprang to their feet.
***
The commotion in the café continued for some time. When the police arrived in response to the call, they took one look at Choi Dae-sik and let out a weary sigh.
This was already the fourth report of him causing a disturbance involving an attorney from Baekmun Motors.
“I know this is a headache, but how can a man who’s lost his wife and child be in his right mind? Let’s try to settle this amicably, Executive Director.”
The police left after urging everyone to be understanding towards Choi Dae-sik. Dae-sik left with his lawyers, leaving only the café staff behind.
Hee-dae, who had been with the officers in the car park, returned to the café and found Yeon-seo studying her laptop screen intently.
He dropped into the seat opposite her. He felt as though he had aged ten years.
“This is exactly why I said we shouldn’t come.”
With a sigh, Hee-dae tugged at his tie.
“What did you expect to achieve by showing up here and putting our faces on display for the whole country to see? It’s clear that Choi Dae-sik’s team will share a maliciously edited version on social media. What on earth were you thinking? Huh?”
Hee-dae gulped down some cold water.
Setting the glass down sharply on the table, he frowned at Yeon-seo. Had she thought anything through at all? Was she really a lawyer?
“What are you going to do now? If you had decisive evidence, you should have presented it in court. Why did you hand the documents over to the other side? Huh?’
‘Infuriating. Absolutely infuriating.’
Hee-dae stared at Yeon-seo, unable to understand her. When she continued to stare at her laptop in silence, he reached over and pulled it towards him.
When he saw the screen, his eyes flashed.
“You’re sitting here shopping after all that? You’ve got it a lot easier than I thought.”
Having discovered that she was browsing a department store’s website, Hee-dae looked back and forth between the screen and her face.
“What is it? What do you want to buy? Is it something you absolutely have to go out and buy today, so you’re looking at—”
“Um, Executive Director.”
“Why? What? What is it?”
Yeon-seo lifted her gaze, still deep in thought.
“I believe Mr. Choi Dae-sik did press the accelerator on the day of the incident.”
“That’s what you said. Anyone can make a mistake.”
“No.”
“…”
“Perhaps he did it deliberately.”
A chilling shudder ran down Hee-dae’s back.