It felt as though he had seen straight through her heart.
In truth, she had never been able to cast aside the lingering doubt that Cadel might still love Violet. That uncertainty had haunted her all along.
As if mocking those very fears, he pressed the truth firmly into her mind.
“I love you.”
“……”
“I loved you in the past as well. When you confessed to me back then, I couldn’t sleep for three days because I was so happy.”
“……”
“If I had been able to break the curse then, as I have in this life, I would have confessed to you just as I am doing now.”
Thud.
Her heart dropped once more.
He had loved her in the past, too?
She had never realized. Not even once.
No—back then, she had believed he loved Violet. She had been certain of it. That was why she despised herself for feeling jealous, for envying Violet.
Jaina shrank as memories from before her return came flooding back.
Cadel’s voice remained painfully vivid—the way he had looked at her with cold contempt and told her to stop tormenting Violet.
As Jaina struggled, still unable to free herself from the weight of those past days, Cadel spoke again.
“But before I could do any of that… you died.”
When he finished, he stared at her without looking away. Something in his gaze made her chest tighten painfully.
Then the question left his lips, and her body went rigid, as though she could scarcely breathe.
“May I ask now… why you chose death?”
She had never imagined that he would realize she had chosen of her own free will to turn away from the world. She had never given him any reason to suspect it. If she thought about it calmly, he hadn’t treated her so badly that it should have driven her to take her own life.
The truth was that the man she loved had looked at her with disgust.
It was the shock of seeing him put a ring on another woman’s finger.
It was also the pain of being accused of losing her sanity just for hitting the woman who had been showing off the ring so smugly in front of her.
So she chose death.
She was not strong enough to endure the full weight of his contempt and revulsion.
Back then, she loved Cadel that deeply. Having grown up without the warmth of her parents’ love or her sisters’ affection, her heart was starved of tenderness.
But now, so much had changed. Even if those same events were to unfold again, she would not choose to throw her life away.
Now she had Elysion standing firmly at her side. She had Jedel, whom she was determined to protect. Then there was Amelie, who had become a cherished friend in all but name.
Compared to her previous life, this one was filled with precious people beyond Jedel. She was happier now — much happier — than she had ever been before.
When that thought crossed her mind, she found herself wondering.
If she had had someone else precious in her life besides Cadel, would her destiny have turned out differently?
If she had not clung so desperately to a part of his heart and allowed it to consume her daily, but instead broadened her perspective and realized that love was not everything, might she have learned to value herself?
Even if she had been bound by divine decree to a marriage she never wanted and had loved someone she could never truly have, could she have been happier?
‘If I think about it that way… perhaps this life truly is a gift from God.’
Jaina made a silent vow that she would never again throw away this second life, granted to her by divine grace, over foolish despair.
“Is it still… difficult to tell me the reason?”
Lost in the chain of her thoughts, Jaina had momentarily drifted away when Cadel’s voice drew her back.
She stared at him for a long moment before speaking calmly.
“It was because of you.”
For a brief instant, Cadel looked stunned. Then, slowly, his expression hardened.
“…What?”
“The day before I resolved to pour all my divine power into the Elim tree and disappear, you came to see me. Do you remember it? You were angry.”
“……!”
“Of course, I was at fault as well. Violet told me that you had given her a ring set with a gemstone to match the color of your eyes. I lost my temper when I heard that. So…”
Cadel, who had been listening with a face drained of color, suddenly frowned and cut her off.
“Wait. A ring? What ring?”
“A ring set with a black gemstone. The one you placed on Violet’s ring finger.”
“I did?”
Cadel’s eyebrows drew together sharply as he insisted that he had never given her such a gift. As she watched him fall silent and search his memories, Jaina’s suspicions hardened into certainty.
If everything Violet had told her was a lie—
“You often gave Violet accessories in the past, didn’t you?”
“…I did?”
“No?”
“No. That can’t be. I only ever gave one—to you.”
‘As I thought…’
Jaina began to recount everything Violet had said to her in the past.
Violet had boasted constantly that Cadel showered her with gifts at every opportunity. She would brag that he treated her like a lover when they were alone. After each rainy season, she would approach Jaina, speaking in deliberately suggestive tones, implying that something intimate had occurred between her and Cadel during those nights.
As Jaina finally gave voice to the words she had been unable to say back then, she felt the heavy knot lodged deep within her chest loosen, if only slightly.
“She kept coming to me, provoking me little by little. It became harder and harder to endure. And then, in the midst of it all, she told me that you had given her a ring set with a gemstone the same color as your eyes.”
“That never happened.”
Cadel frowned, as though wronged.
Jaina nodded and continued.
“I should have come to you and asked. But as you know, back then there was something awkward and uncomfortable between us, wasn’t there?”
“……”
“I loved you, so I was always cautious—constantly watching your mood. And whenever it involved Violet, you were especially cold and sharp with me. I didn’t have the courage to ask.”
“That was…”
“In any case, when I heard that you had given her a ring meant for a lover — a ring for the ring finger — I thought you were disregarding me, your wife. I lost my senses. So I slapped Violet for humiliating me so blatantly. Regardless of the reason, violence cannot be justified. I admit that was my fault.”
The memory still felt unpleasant. Jaina swallowed, her throat dry.
“You came to see me that day. You were furious. You looked at me with contempt and said things that felt closer to hatred than anger.”
“What? I never—”
“Perhaps you didn’t find their words cruel. Maybe you thought they were just facts. Maybe you thought you were setting someone straight who couldn’t see the truth. But I didn’t understand that back then.”
“……”
“And unlike now… back then, being hated by you felt no different from being cast into hell.”
Jaina looked at Cadel and gave him a faint, sorrowful smile.
“I couldn’t imagine surviving in that hell. So I returned the divine power God had given me to the Elim tree.”
A breath escaped Cadel’s lips, sounding like a broken lament; it was almost a gasp.
He had never imagined that Jaina’s death was his fault.
The truth hit him with a force beyond words.
It meant that he had killed her. And somehow brought her back.
Overwhelmed by pain beyond his ability to withstand it, Cadel covered his face with both hands and let out a low, strangled groan.
Seeing him like that, Jaina’s eyes widened in shock. She lifted her hands towards him in alarm, unsure how to help.
“It wasn’t your fault. Back then, I…”
“It was because of me.”
Cadel looked at Jaina as though in agony.
“You died because of me. And I didn’t even know…”
“If we must place blame, then it was Violet’s fault. And mine—for believing her lies.”
“……”
“Of course you share some of the blame. If you had shown me even the slightest bit of care, I would have come to you and asked if what Violet said was true.”
“There was nothing I could do back then. What kind of confession could a husband make when he was forced to leave his wife every night to go to another woman’s room?”
Cadel explained that he had tried to spare her pain in his own way.
Once he realized that she loved him, he wanted to return that love. But his circumstances had made it impossible, and that reality had tormented him.
The only thing he believed he could do was to ensure, as far as possible, that Jaina would not be troubled by Violet. That was why he avoided speaking of Violet in her presence whenever possible.
A look of quiet anguish settled over his face.
“Every rainy night, I had to leave my wife and go to another woman’s room. That was all I could do.”
“……”
“I didn’t know Violet was tormenting you like that. If I had known, I would have done something—anything…”
His voice faltered as if his throat had closed. He took a long, steadying breath.
Jaina looked at him intently.
If only they had spoken like this in the past, would their relationship have been different?
The weight of all the time they had allowed to slip away without saying anything now pressed heavily against her chest.
“So that’s why… in this life, you chose not to stay by my side.”
Cadel’s eyes, which were faintly glistening, met hers.
They were not brimming with tears. He wasn’t sobbing like a child. And yet the mere sheen in his gaze made her heart feel as though it were collapsing.
Jaina swallowed against the tightness in her throat and answered quietly.
“I believed that even in this life, you would cherish Violet more than me.”
“No!”
Upon hearing her words, Cadel cried out and lowered his head, almost shouting.
She felt an overwhelming urge to pull him into her arms.
Seeing a man stronger than anyone else in the world bow his head before her caused her great pain. In that moment, he seemed more fragile than anyone else.
Then a single tear fell from Cadel’s lowered eyelid.
Jaina’s eyes widened in shock.
In a voice barely above a whisper, he said,
“I’m sorry.”